Amish Chocolate Chip Cookies

Who doesn't love classic chocolate chip cookies? These soft and chewy Amish Chocolate Chip Cookies save tradition while also adding a vanilla butterscotch twist. Have you ever added vanilla or butterscotch pudding mix to your cookies? This recipe makes for the softest and chewiest chocolate chip cookies ever. You won't be disappointed!

They are the perfect dessert for any occasion and we guarantee they won't last long. Serve these Amish chocolate chip cookies at large gatherings, or lunches, or pack them for friends and family.

If you have never added pudding to your chocolate chip batter, then you are in for a treat! The pudding in the dough mixture makes for super soft, thick, and chewy chocolate chip cookie dough. We recommend trying this combination if you have never tried instant pudding in your cookie mixture.

This recipe yields about 4 dozen cookies. We recommend either halving the recipe or freezing half the batch to make sure you’ll get through these cookies!

If you love this recipe, we also recommend checking out Amish Peanut Butter Cookies or Amish Butter Cookies. For a delicious fruitier cookie, try out Amish Apple Cookies. You won't be disappointed!

How to make soft Amish Chocolate Chip Cookies?

The secret to making soft and chewy Amish Chocolate Chip Cookies is baking them quickly in a hot oven. These cookies only need about 10-12 minutes to bake. Let cool properly and you will have the most amazing soft Amish Chocolate Chip Cookies.

What are other variations of Amish chocolate chip cookies with pudding?

Try mixing up this recipe by trying out different pudding flavors like pumpkin pudding, chocolate, or banana pudding. The options are endless!

Looking for more Amish home inspiration?

This Amish-crafted decorative Hanging Mail Organizer Rack is the perfect organizational tool crafted to hold letters, magazines, and other papers in two separate compartments, making it easy to organize and sort your mail and bills.

The quality is unbeatable and you will love the way this basket looks in your kitchen or entryway

Amish Chocolate Chip Cookies

Rated 2.7 stars by 6 users

• Share on Twitter
• Share on Facebook
• Share on Pinterest
• Share on Whatsapp

Category

Amish Cookies

Cuisine

Amish Food

Servings

4 Dozen

Prep Time

10 minutes

Cook Time

10-12 minutes

Amish Chocolate Chip cookies are like traditional chocolate chip cookies with a vanilla and butterscotch twist. These recipes call for vanilla and butterscotch instant pudding which make the softest and chewiest cookies ever. Try switching up the flavoring to make your own unique chocolate chip cookie recipe. We guarantee this recipe will quickly become your go-to chocolate chip cookie recipe.

Author:

Mrs. Raymond Yutzy

Ingredients

• 1 c. butter, softened

• 1 c. vegetable oil

• 1 1/2 c. sugar

• 2 c. brown sugar

• 5 eggs

• 2 Tbsp. vanilla

• 1 tsp. lemon flavoring

• 3 tsp. baking soda

• 1 tsp. salt

• 4 c. chocolate chips

• 1/2 c. instant vanilla pudding

• 1/2 c. instant butterscotch pudding

• 6 1/2 c. flour

View Cart (0) Checkout

Directions

1. Preheat the oven to 375°. Cream together butter, oil, and sugar. Then mix in beaten eggs.

   

2. Add dry ingredients; flour, pudding mix, and baking soda. Then fold in chocolate chips.

   

3. Roll tablespoon size balls of dough. Place on a greased cookie sheet or parchment paper.

   

4. Bake for 15 minutes until the edges are brown. Let cool

   

Recipe Note

For flatter cookies, flatten dough balls with a floured spoon. Cook for 2-3 minutes less.

Allow cookies to fully rest for at least 10 minutes on a flat resting counter. The pudding makes this cookie so soft that it may break apart on a cooling rack.

Use soft butter or margarine. Melted butter also is okay.

To replace vegetable oil, just add 1 cup of butter.

How to Store Amish Chocolate Chip Cookies?

Store in a well-sealed container for 3-5 days. To freeze, place cooled cookies on a baking sheet and set them in the freezer for 30 minutes.

How to Reheat Frozen Amish Chocolate Chip Cookies?

Choose to thaw cookies or place them straight into the oven. Add 1-3 minutes to the baking time for frozen cookies.

More Amish Cookie Recipes:

Amish Church Cookies

Amish Peanut Butter Cookies

Amish Snickerdoodle Cookies