Amish Comfort
Handmade goods from a simpler time. Jam, goat milk soap, candles, gift baskets, and chocolate, all made by Old-Order Amish families and sent to your door with free shipping.
25,959 five-star reviews Lifetime guarantee Free shipping, always
Homemade Jam
Put up the old-fashioned way, a few jars at a time.
Amish
Amish Strawberry Jam
Real strawberries, two 10 oz jars
Amish
Amish Apple Butter
Apples and cinnamon, two 10 oz jars
Amish
Amish Peach Jam
Real peaches, two 10 oz jars
Borntrager Family
Amish Jam Gift Basket
Three 10 oz jars of Amish jam in a signed basket: 9 x 6 x 3.
Borntrager Family
Heart Shaped Gift Basket
Two 10 oz jars of Amish jam in a heart basket: 8 x 8 x 3 1/2.
Borntrager Family
“Jam Gift Basket” Collection (10 Baskets)
Ten signed jam baskets, three jars of jam in each, in one box.
Goat Milk Soaps
Gentle, simple soaps handmade by the families.
Amish
Milk 'n Honey Natural Amish Goat Milk Soap
Honey-scented goat milk bar, 5 oz
Amish
Lavender Soap
Goat's milk, oats and honey, 5 oz
Borntrager Family
Goat Soap Gift Basket
Three goat's milk soaps in a signed basket: 9 x 6 x 3.
Amish
Vanilla Cream Amish Goat Milk Soap
Vanilla cream with ground oats, 5 oz
Borntrager Family
Heart Shaped Goat Soap Gift Basket
Two goat's milk soaps in a heart basket: 8 x 8 x 3 1/2.
Gingerich Family
Wood-Handled Goat Soap Basket
Three goat's milk soaps in the little handled basket: 5 1/2 in.
Handmade Candles
Handmade candles for a warm and quiet home.
Amish
Amish Golden Harvest
Apple and cinnamon, about 70 hours
Amish
Amish Cranberry Spice
Cranberry and clove, about 70 hours
Amish
Amish Hope's Blossom
Jasmine and orange, about 70 hours
Amish
Amish Rose Valley
Rose and magnolia, about 70 hours
Borntrager Family
Amish Christmas Candle Gift Basket
Two Christmas soy candles in a signed basket: 9 x 6 x 3.
Borntrager Family
Amish Spring Candles Gift Basket
Two spring soy candles in a signed basket: 9 x 6 x 3.
Amish
Amish Berry Meadow
Cherry and raspberry, about 70 hours
Amish
Amish Minty Mocha
Peppermint mocha, about 70 hours
Gift Baskets
Handmade gift baskets for every occasion.
Borntrager Family
Amish Jam Gift Basket
Three 10 oz jars of Amish jam in a signed basket: 9 x 6 x 3.
Borntrager Family
Chocolate Lover’s Gift Basket
Peanut clusters and toffee bars in a signed basket: 9 x 6 x 3.
Borntrager Family
Heart Shaped Chocolate Gift Basket
Peanut clusters and toffee bars in a heart basket: 8 x 8.
Borntrager Family
Heart Shaped Gift Basket
Two 10 oz jars of Amish jam in a heart basket: 8 x 8 x 3 1/2.
Borntrager Family
Goat Soap Gift Basket
Three goat's milk soaps in a signed basket: 9 x 6 x 3.
Borntrager Family
Heart Shaped Goat Soap Gift Basket
Two goat's milk soaps in a heart basket: 8 x 8 x 3 1/2.
Borntrager Family
Amish Christmas Candle Gift Basket
Two Christmas soy candles in a signed basket: 9 x 6 x 3.
Borntrager Family
Amish Spring Candles Gift Basket
Two spring soy candles in a signed basket: 9 x 6 x 3.
Handmade Chocolate
Small-batch chocolate and candy, made by hand and shipped in cool weather.
Amish
Chocolate Covered Peanuts
Salted peanuts, chocolate coating
Amish
English Toffee Candy
Buttery toffee bars, two 12 oz bags
Borntrager Family
Chocolate Lover’s Gift Basket
Peanut clusters and toffee bars in a signed basket: 9 x 6 x 3.
Borntrager Family
Heart Shaped Chocolate Gift Basket
Peanut clusters and toffee bars in a heart basket: 8 x 8.
Amish
Amish Peanut Brittle
Classic hard brittle, two 12 oz bags
Handmade Goods From a Simpler Time
For hundreds of years, the Amish have been dedicated to creating high-quality handmade goods. Each item is thoughtfully crafted by an Amish family, with skill and care passed down through many generations. When you purchase authentic Amish homemade goods, you help keep those traditional skills alive and well for the next generation.
Looking for a Gift?
The gift guide gathers handmade favorites by recipient, budget, and occasion.