Skip to content
FREE SHIPPING - On All Orders!
FREE SHIPPING - On All Orders!

Amish Handmade Gifts Under $50

Genuine Amish hand-crafted gifts for someone special and available for under $50.00 (and shipping of your gift is free!). Each collectible handmade gift will be an unforgettable heirloom and enjoyed for a lifetime.
  • Vanilla Cream Natural Amish Goat Milk Soap | With Oats & Honey

    Original price $ 22.50 - Original price $ 37.50
    Original price $ 22.50 - Original price $ 37.50
    Original price $ 22.50
    $ 17.95 - $ 29.95
    $ 17.95 - $ 29.95
    Current price $ 17.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    Made with real goat's milk! Enhanced with oats and honey! Helps skin look younger and vibrant! Includes natural coconut oil! Handcrafted in small...

    View full details
  • Milk 'n Honey Natural Amish Goat Milk Soap | With Oats & Honey

    Original price $ 22.50 - Original price $ 37.50
    Original price $ 22.50 - Original price $ 37.50
    Original price $ 22.50
    $ 17.95 - $ 29.95
    $ 17.95 - $ 29.95
    Current price $ 17.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    Made with real goat's milk! Enhanced with oats and honey! Helps skin look younger and vibrant! Includes natural coconut oil! Handcrafted in small...

    View full details
  • Lavender Natural Amish Goat Milk Soap | With Oats & Honey

    Original price $ 22.50 - Original price $ 37.50
    Original price $ 22.50 - Original price $ 37.50
    Original price $ 22.50
    $ 17.95 - $ 29.95
    $ 17.95 - $ 29.95
    Current price $ 17.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    Made with real goat's milk! Enhanced with oats and honey! Helps skin look younger and vibrant! Includes natural coconut oil! Handcrafted in small...

    View full details
  • Amish Sleigh Ride | 16 oz. Natural Soy Farmhouse Candle

    Original price $ 27.50 - Original price $ 43.50
    Original price $ 27.50 - Original price $ 43.50
    Original price $ 27.50
    $ 21.95 - $ 34.95
    $ 21.95 - $ 34.95
    Current price $ 21.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    Experience the aromatic scents of an actual Amish sleigh ride over a frosty, snow-covered trail on a brisk winter’s evening. This one-of-a-kind ca...

    View full details
  • Amish Old Christmas | 16 oz. Natural Soy Farmhouse Candle

    Original price $ 27.50 - Original price $ 43.50
    Original price $ 27.50 - Original price $ 43.50
    Original price $ 27.50
    $ 21.95 - $ 34.95
    $ 21.95 - $ 34.95
    Current price $ 21.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    You will quickly notice that the heart of this premium soy candle’s refreshing scent is the Amish tradition of baking a delicious assortment of cr...

    View full details
  • Amish Homemade Apple Butter | 10 oz Each

    Original price $ 31.50 - Original price $ 46.50
    Original price $ 31.50 - Original price $ 46.50
    Original price $ 31.50
    $ 24.95 - $ 38.95
    $ 24.95 - $ 38.95
    Current price $ 24.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    Homemade taste of yesteryear! Loaded with fresh-picked fruit! Award-winning, fresh fruit taste! Secret ingredient for extra flavor! Handcrafted i...

    View full details
  • Amish Homemade Peach Jam | 10 oz Each

    Original price $ 31.50 - Original price $ 46.50
    Original price $ 31.50 - Original price $ 46.50
    Original price $ 31.50
    $ 24.95 - $ 38.95
    $ 24.95 - $ 38.95
    Current price $ 24.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    Homemade taste of yesteryear! Loaded with fresh-picked fruit! Award-winning, fresh fruit taste! Secret ingredient for extra flavor! Handcrafted i...

    View full details
  • Amish Homemade Strawberry Jam | 10 oz Each

    Original price $ 31.50 - Original price $ 46.50
    Original price $ 31.50 - Original price $ 46.50
    Original price $ 31.50
    $ 24.95 - $ 38.95
    $ 24.95 - $ 38.95
    Current price $ 24.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    Homemade taste of yesteryear! Loaded with fresh-picked fruit! Award-winning, fresh fruit taste! Secret ingredient for extra flavor! Handcrafted i...

    View full details
  • Homemade Chocolate Toffee Bars | 12 oz Each Bag

    Original price $ 37.50 - Original price $ 62.50
    Original price $ 37.50 - Original price $ 62.50
    Original price $ 37.50
    $ 29.95 - $ 49.95
    $ 29.95 - $ 49.95
    Current price $ 29.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    3/4 pound in each bag! Buttery almond toffee! Smothered with creamy milk chocolate! Freshly roasted almonds! Handcrafted in small batches! Craft...

    View full details
  • Homemade Chocolate Peanut Clusters | 12 oz Each Bag

    Original price $ 37.50 - Original price $ 62.50
    Original price $ 37.50 - Original price $ 62.50
    Original price $ 37.50
    $ 29.95 - $ 49.95
    $ 29.95 - $ 49.95
    Current price $ 29.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    3/4 pound of clusters in each bag! Fresh, homemade taste! Creamy Milk Chocolate! Packed with freshly roasted peanuts! Handcrafted in small batche...

    View full details
  • Handy Catch-All Basket | Small Amish Trinket Basket

    Original price $ 48.95
    Original price $ 48.95 - Original price $ 48.95
    Original price $ 48.95
    Current price $ 38.95
    $ 38.95 - $ 38.95
    Current price $ 38.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    This rustic farmhouse styled woven wooden decorative catch-all basket is handmade by Amish families in the Heartland. This small trinket basket i...

    View full details
  • Heart Shaped Counter Basket | Small Amish Candy & Trinket Basket

    Original price $ 49.95
    Original price $ 49.95 - Original price $ 49.95
    Original price $ 49.95
    Current price $ 39.95
    $ 39.95 - $ 39.95
    Current price $ 39.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    This rustic farmhouse-style heart-shaped catch-all or candy basket is handmade by Amish families in the Heartland. This small wicker basket is cr...

    View full details
  • Candy & Gift Giving Basket | Amish Wicker Basket w/Handle

    Original price $ 53.95
    Original price $ 53.95 - Original price $ 53.95
    Original price $ 53.95
    Current price $ 42.95
    $ 42.95 - $ 42.95
    Current price $ 42.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    From keeping candies or other small treats readily accessible on your counter, to creating the most memorable gift basket filled with cookies or o...

    View full details
  • Napkin Holder Basket | Amish Woven Wicker Table Top Basket

    Original price $ 56.95
    Original price $ 56.95 - Original price $ 56.95
    Original price $ 56.95
    Current price $ 44.95
    $ 44.95 - $ 44.95
    Current price $ 44.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    This Amish handmade wicker napkin holder is a classy and convenient way to store your napkins. This napkin basket will hold a nice stack of napki...

    View full details
  • Woven Fruit & Bread Basket | Round Wicker for Home or Restaurant

    Original price $ 61.95
    Original price $ 61.95 - Original price $ 61.95
    Original price $ 61.95
    Current price $ 48.95
    $ 48.95 - $ 48.95
    Current price $ 48.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    What better way to serve your fresh baked, handmade bread, bagels, rolls and pastries than with a lovingly handmade, Amish woven wicker bread serv...

    View full details
  • Dinner Roll Basket | Amish Wicker Small Bread Basket

    Original price $ 62.95
    Original price $ 62.95 - Original price $ 62.95
    Original price $ 62.95
    Current price $ 49.95
    $ 49.95 - $ 49.95
    Current price $ 49.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    This Amish handmade vintage Bread Basket is a beautiful and inviting way to serve your warmed bread or rolls at the dinner table. This versatile ...

    View full details
  • Fruit & Vegetable Basket | Amish Produce Basket w/Leather Handles

    Original price $ 62.95
    Original price $ 62.95 - Original price $ 62.95
    Original price $ 62.95
    Current price $ 49.95
    $ 49.95 - $ 49.95
    Current price $ 49.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    This beautiful Amish handmade fruit wicker basket with handles is perfect for any home, garden, country or primitive décor. You can fill it with f...

    View full details
  • Square Woven Bread Basket | Amish Wicker w/Optional Napkin Liner

    Original price $ 62.95
    Original price $ 62.95 - Original price $ 62.95
    Original price $ 62.95
    Current price $ 49.95
    $ 49.95 - $ 49.95
    Current price $ 49.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    This rustic, Amish woven wicker basket is perfect for hundreds of uses around your home and kitchen. This serving and display basket is designed t...

    View full details
  • Heart Shaped Goat Soap Gift Basket | Fresh Amish Goat Soap Gift Set

    Original price $ 62.50
    Original price $ 62.50 - Original price $ 62.50
    Original price $ 62.50
    Current price $ 49.95
    $ 49.95 - $ 49.95
    Current price $ 49.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    Give the gift of gentle cleansing with this premium, heart-shaped, homemade goat’s milk soap basket that will surely be loved by everyone. Each s...

    View full details
  • Bread Serving Basket | Amish Wicker Large Bread Basket

    Original price $ 67.95
    Original price $ 67.95 - Original price $ 67.95
    Original price $ 67.95
    Current price $ 53.95
    $ 53.95 - $ 53.95
    Current price $ 53.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    This Amish handmade bread basket with handle will add down-home goodness to every serving of warm bread or buns that you put on your table. This h...

    View full details
  • Small Woven Waste Basket | 10" Amish Wicker Wastebasket

    Original price $ 67.95
    Original price $ 67.95 - Original price $ 67.95
    Original price $ 67.95
    Current price $ 53.95
    $ 53.95 - $ 53.95
    Current price $ 53.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    This genuine Amish hand woven wicker waste basket is perfect for any room in your home from your bedroom to your bathroom. This wastebasket and tr...

    View full details
  • Medium Lazy Susan Basket | 10" Amish Woven Wicker Table Top Basket

    Original price $ 68.95
    Original price $ 68.95 - Original price $ 68.95
    Original price $ 68.95
    Current price $ 54.95
    $ 54.95 - $ 54.95
    Current price $ 54.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    This Amish handmade vintage kitchen lazy Susan is a wonderful addition to any room in your home. Use this beautiful basket as a centerpiece on the...

    View full details
  • Square Tissue Box Holder | Amish Wicker Kleenex Box Cover

    Original price $ 68.95
    Original price $ 68.95 - Original price $ 68.95
    Original price $ 68.95
    Current price $ 54.95
    $ 54.95 - $ 54.95
    Current price $ 54.95
    Delivered In 5-7 Days

    This Amish handmade Tissue Box Topper Basket is the perfect way to hide those unsightly tissue boxes. This square tissue box holder is custom desi...

    View full details