The Amish Gift Guide
We did not guess at this page. More than 3,600 of our reviews mention giving a basket as a gift, so every pick below is ranked by the people who actually gave one.
25,822+ five-star reviews Lifetime guarantee Free shipping, always
The Most-Gifted Baskets
Ranked by how often customers tell us they gave one as a gift.
Yoder Family
Knitting Basket
Yoder Family
Recipe Card Box
Yoder Family
Dual Pie Carrier
Yoder Family
Large Vintage Picnic Basket
Mast Family
Large Sewing & Craft Basket
Mast Family
Bread Serving Basket
Yoder Family
Christmas Sleigh Centerpiece
Mast Family
Large Picnic Basket
For Your Daughter
Daughters and daughters-in-law are the #1 people our customers buy gifts for.
“I ordered this for my daughter!! It is lovely and certainly a piece to pass on to her daughter!!”
- Paula K., Verified Buyer
For Mom & Grandma
Pieces that go straight into daily use, from the kitchen table to the knitting chair.
“It was a Mother's Day present. My wife was very surprised with the gift.”
- Barry R., Verified Buyer
For the Baker
Pie carriers and bread baskets are some of the most-gifted things we make.
“I gave the basket to my sister as a gift today and she loved how it looked and that the note said it could be fixed if it was ever broken.”
- Deirdre D., Verified Buyer
For Picnics & the Garden
Customer favorites for weddings, anniversaries, and new homes.
“I bought this for a wedding gift and liked it so much I bought one for myself and my husband of course!!”
- Michelle K., Verified Buyer
Shop by Budget
Thoughtful, handmade gifts at every price.
Gifting Made Easy
Your gift ships free, packed with care and never marked with a price. Add a free gift note at checkout, and every piece carries the signature of the Amish crafter who made it.
Free shipping · No prices in the box · Free gift note at checkout · Signed by the maker
Gift Questions, Answered
The things gift-givers ask us most often.
Yes. There is a free gift note option at checkout, and we never include prices in the box.
Still Deciding?
Browse what is selling fastest right now, or see the whole gift store.