The Amish Gift Guide
We did not guess at this page. More than 3,600 of our reviews mention giving a basket as a gift, so every pick below is ranked by the people who actually gave one.
25,959 five-star reviews Lifetime guarantee Free shipping, always
The Most-Gifted Baskets
Ranked by how often customers tell us they gave one as a gift.
Yoder Family
Knitting Basket
3 yarn compartments, lid with feed holes
Yoder Family
Recipe Card Box
4 x 6 cards under a wood lid with a little wooden ledge: 7 1/2 x 7 x 6.
Mast Family
Dual Pie Carrier
Two pies stacked on a legged shelf: 14 in. round, 7 1/2 tall.
Yoder Family
Large Vintage Picnic Basket
The family size: 19 1/2 x 13 1/2, fixed handle, hinged lid.
Mast Family
Large Sewing & Craft Basket
Lidded top, pull-out drawer, 15 1/2 inches
Mast Family
Bread Serving Basket
A sliced loaf at the table: 13 x 7 with leather loop handles.
Yoder Family
Christmas Sleigh Centerpiece
A sleigh for the greens and ornaments: 17 1/2 x 8 x 10 tall.
Mast Family
Large Picnic Basket
The family hamper: 22 x 13 x 10, a shelf inside, sets for 2 to 6.
For Your Daughter
Daughters and daughters-in-law are often the ones our customers are shopping for.
“I ordered this for my daughter!! It is lovely and certainly a piece to pass on to her daughter!!”
- Paula K., Verified Buyer
Mast Family
Triple Pie Basket
Three pies on two shelves: 14 in. round, 11 tall.
Mast Family
Vintage Sewing Basket
Divided tray on top, 25 thread pegs below
Swarey Family
Square Two Pie Carrier
Two pies stacked, square, doubles as a picnic basket: 12 x 12.
Borntrager Family
Heart Shaped Gift Basket
Two 10 oz jars of Amish jam in a heart basket: 8 x 8 x 3 1/2.
For Mom & Grandma
Pieces that go straight into daily use, from the kitchen table to the knitting chair.
“It was a Mother's Day present. My wife was very surprised with the gift.”
- Barry R., Verified Buyer
Yoder Family
Knitting Bag
Soft-sided, 4 yarn grommets in the handle
Yoder Family
Antique Styled Sewing Basket
14 inch round with lid, on a 12 1/2 inch stand
Mast Family
Large Tabletop Lazy Susan
Spins on a base that stays still: 12 in. across, 3 1/2 sides.
Borntrager Family
Farmhouse Table Centerpiece
Down the middle of the table: 27 1/2 x 7 x 3 1/2.
For the Knitter or Crocheter
The Knitting Basket is a favorite gift, and the rest of the knitting family follows it.
“This was a gift for my sister who is an avid knitter. It was so beautiful it brought her to tears. Thanks so much”
- Di W., Verified Buyer
Yoder Family
Homestead Knitting Basket
Open 20 inch chest, lift-off lid, feet
Yoder Family
The Yarn Barn
4 compartments, project shelf, drawer
Yoder Family
Vintage Yarn Caddy
Open caddy, leather handles, 6 in tall
Swarey Family
Knitting Needle Organizer
Upright, needles to 16 in, hooks too
For the Baker
Pie carriers and bread baskets are among the favorite gifts.
“I gave the basket to my sister as a gift today and she loved how it looked and that the note said it could be fixed if it was ever broken.”
- Deirdre D., Verified Buyer
Yoder Family
Single Pie Carrier
One pie under a wood lid: 14 in. round, 4 1/2 tall.
Yoder Family
Wood Handled Pie Carrier
Two pies, swinging wood handles: 14 in. round, 7 1/2 tall.
Yoder Family
Square Woven Bread Basket
Square, 11 x 11, the napkin tucks through the corners.
Yoder Family
Amish Bread Box
A loaf and a half under a hinged wood lid: 17 x 9 x 8 1/2.
For Picnics & the Garden
Customer favorites for weddings, anniversaries, and new homes.
“I bought this for a wedding gift and liked it so much I bought one for myself and my husband of course!!”
- Michelle K., Verified Buyer
Swarey Family
Traditional Picnic Basket
Lift-off lid, leather straps, a legged shelf inside: 18 x 13 x 10.
Mast Family
Amish Picnic Basket
Two 9 x 13 dishes under a lift-off lid: 17 1/2 x 14 x 9 1/2.
Yoder Family
Garden Gathering Basket
5 inch sides, one wood handle
Yoder Family
Small Wicker Egg Basket
Holds up to 36 eggs, fixed hoop handle: 9 across, 9 tall.
Shop by Budget
Thoughtful, handmade gifts at every price.
Gifting Made Easy
Your gift ships free, packed with care and never marked with a price. Add a free gift note at checkout, and every piece carries the signature of the Amish crafter who made it.
Free shipping · No prices in the box · Free gift note at checkout · Signed by the maker
Gift Questions, Answered
The things gift-givers ask us most often.
Yes. There is a free gift note option at checkout, and we never include prices in the box.
Still Deciding?
Browse what is selling fastest right now, or see the whole gift store.