Skip to content
Order Now - Free Shipping Before Christmas - Guaranteed!
Order Now - Free Shipping Before Christmas - Guaranteed!

Amish Homemade Apple Butter | 10 oz Each

by Amish

Original price $ 31.50
Original price $ 31.50 - Original price $ 46.50
Original price $ 31.50
Current price $ 24.95
$ 24.95 - $ 38.95
Current price $ 24.95
Choose Quantity: 2 Jars
FREE Delivery In 5-7 Days
FREE Delivery In 5-7 Days

"It tastes just like the apple butter my mother made years ago." - Leonita N.


You can return any basket at any time for repair, replacement, or a refund - your choice, with no questions asked.

  • Homemade taste of yesteryear!
  • Loaded with fresh-picked fruit!
  • Award-winning, fresh fruit taste!
  • Secret ingredient for extra flavor!
  • Handcrafted in small batches!
  • Crafted with love by Old-Order Amish!

Each delectable flavor of our homemade jams and butter spreads are handmade in Lena Mast's kitchen. Lena uses only natural fruits picked from the tree at the peak of freshness. Each 10-ounce jar of delightfully-delicious apple butter spread is bursting with the simple goodness of days gone by. This fruit spread contains only pure, natural ingredients without any artificial flavors or preservatives.


More About Lena And Her Love Of Making Sweet Jams And Butters...

Lena grew up in the kitchen with her mother and grandmother. She learned the family recipes to make the finest fruit preserves, jams, and butters as they have been handed down in her Old-Order Amish family for generations. She learned the importance of using the finest and freshest fruits. She learned to respect the importance of carefully measuring each quality ingredient and patiently watching over each pot while it cooked.

One of Lena's favorite items to prepare has always been her family's deliciously-sweet recipes for jams and fruit butters. From the time Lena was a child, her ability to turn each fresh fruit harvest into jams, jellies, and preserves that the family could enjoy all year long has held a special place in her heart.


A Secret Ingredient Discovered Just a Few Years Ago...

As outrageous as it sounded, earlier in the year, the ladies in our local Amish community set out to discover if Lena's recipes could be made even more mouthwatering than they already were. This event took on the feel of a community-wide "cook-off" contest that everyone in the community thoroughly enjoyed. Each person was tasked with finding out if they could make any improvements to the age-old jam and spread recipes Lena was using.


The Winner Is You!

Needless to say, there was not much room for improvement available since the original recipes already produced the finest-tasting jams around, but... There was one special "twist" that was discovered during the entire process. It was discovered that if she took out the small amount of water that she used in the recipes to begin the "fruit breakdown" process and replaced it with a small amount of fruit juice instead, it gave her recipes a subtle yet dynamically-delectable new taste and took each of her jam flavors to an entirely new level of deliciousness.

When you try this special homemade apple butter we are sure you will agree that it is the most unique and delicious spreadable treat you have ever tasted. You will discover why these Lena's recipe was awarded the label of being the best-tasting in our Amish community.


Measures: 2 1/2" diameter x 4 1/2" tall