Free Shipping On All Orders

why is amish food so good

Why is Amish Food So Good?

Amish food is renowned for its deliciousness and wholesomeness. Most people who have tried Amish dishes describe them as sweet, rich, and hearty.

Why is Amish food so good? This food has been around for centuries, with recipes that have been handed down from generation to generation and have been perfected over time. Additionally, Amish people take pride in supporting their local farmers and producers. All the ingredients they use to make a meal are locally sourced and free from preservatives and additives.

Amish recipes are simple yet flavorful, making them perfect for a home-cooked meal. Daily dishes often include hearty meats such as pork chops, ham, roast beef, or meatloaf; dairy products like eggs and cheese; potatoes and vegetables; and desserts like shoofly pie or doughnuts.

These ingredients come together to create a unique flavor that can't be found anywhere else. Basically, Amish food is homemade comfort food, which is why it's so good.

What this article covers:

How Do the Amish Cook?

The Amish have hearty breakfasts but may prefer light or heavy lunches depending on family work and school schedules. Traditional Amish food is as simple as the handmade Amish dolls that little girls play with. This community has no dietary restrictions, and they are not shy to use butter, sugar, and cream generously to add flavor to various dishes.

what makes Amish food delicious


Baking is an essential part of Amish culture. They rely on a few simple ingredients to make delicious puddings, pies, muffins, doughnuts, and cookies. Do the Amish have refrigerators for their pies? Most of thems still use iceboxes and other traditional methods to preserve their pies and food, although some Amish settlements allow solar or gas-powered refrigerators. 

Savory Dishes

Amish food and community bonds

Savory foods like soups, stews, and casseroles are just as important to the Amish. Soups with hearty vegetables like potatoes and carrots for a filling meal or stews with slow-cooked beef are common. Also, baked casseroles with layers of potatoes, cheeses, and meats are usually served for dinner.

Do Amish eat pork? Meat, eggs, and dairy products are integral to the Amish diet. They raise chickens, cows, and pigs for food. Pork is a favorite because of its affordability and availability in local markets.

Cooking Method

The Amish cook their dishes on a wood-burning stove or over an open fire. This cooking method brings out the natural flavors in all ingredients. Additionally, the cooks use cast iron pots and pans. These pots and pans retain heat better, giving their dishes that classic, home-cooked flavor everyone loves.

Amish culinary practices

What Are Some Amish Specialties?

Amish women and girls make three home-cooked meals a day. Do Amish drink alcohol? The Amish have strict rules that ban alcohol use. Their meals don’t include a glass of wine like regular English meals. These are some of Amish specialties:

Coffee Soup

Do Amish drink coffee? They do. In fact, coffee soup is a common breakfast dish in Amish country. It’s made of coffee and generous amounts of cream and sugar.

Coffee soup is served with a side of bread for dunking, eggs, or ham. Sometimes it includes onions, potatoes, and vegetables.

Chow Chow

Amish chow-chow compliments lots of dishes. This pickled relish is made by stewing together green tomatoes, cabbage, peppers, cauliflower, and other vegetables in vinegar. It’s often served alongside meats such as chicken, pork chops, and beef.

Amish homemade food

Shoofly Pie

This is a type of molasses-based pie. Shoofly pie is semi-sweet with a sticky texture usually served as dessert. It has a crumble top made of flour and butter that adds to the texture and flavor of the pie.

Dutch Cabbage Rolls

Dutch cabbage rolls are a culinary tradition in Lancaster county. The Amish often eat them on Sundays when the whole family gathers together. To make this dish, women boil cabbage leaves and fill them with a mixture of ground beef, pork, onions, and spices. They then roll and bake them in the oven.

What Makes Amish Food Taste So Good?

Most people who’ve tried Amish cuisine agree that it’s delicious. Here are some of the reasons Amish food tastes so good.

Farm-fresh Ingredients

Although the Amish buy produce from local stores occasionally, they mostly use ingredients from their own farms. Each woman owns a garden harvest basket to carry fresh ingredients for tasty, nutritious, and high-quality food.

Amish food culture

Authentic Recipes

The recipes for Amish dishes have been passed down generations and have been perfected over time. The Amish are very particular about preparing their meals and have been perfecting their recipes for centuries. They’re also very particular about how they store their baked goods. You'll find a bread box in every home to help keep the bread and biscuits fresh.

Amish recipes and cooking techniques


Another element that helps give Amish food its unique flavors is spices. Unlike most modern-day cuisines, which prefer herbs & seasonings to add flavor, the Amish stick to traditional spices like pepper or paprika for their dishes - making each one even more flavorful than you could imagine.

Additionally, they use special tools such as mortar & pestle to grind various types of herbs & spices into a fine paste or powder.

Slow-Cooking Technique

The secret behind this impressive cuisine is the traditional methods used in its preparation.

Unlike other cuisines, Amish food does not rely heavily on modern appliances such as microwaves, electric ovens, and blenders. Instead, all cooking is done over an open fire or stovetop using only natural ingredients such as butter and lard to create savory dishes full of flavor.

Simple recipes are slow-cooked over a stovetop to retain as much flavor as possible. This method requires patience but yields a meal that rivals many restaurant-prepared dishes!

Amish and farm-to-table cooking


If you’re a fan of home-cooked meals full of flavor and warmth, then Amish cuisine is for you! From the simple yet delicious dishes made with fresh local ingredients to the hearty and comforting soups & stews, Amish cooking offers plenty of tasty options that will make your taste buds sing.

Did You Find Our Blog Helpful? Then Consider Checking:

Previous post
Next post
Back to Blog